Confession in Buddhism

Buddhism from the beginning has a tradition of confessing one’s transgressions to others as a way of setting things right. It’s also thought in some schools of thought to also diminish the effects of bad karma, or at the very least create some small good karma to offset the bad.

Confession here comes in many forms. The Theravada monk and all-round-nice-guy, Ajahn Brahm, teaches the simple concept of A.F.L.:

  • Acknowledge
  • Forgive yourself
  • Learn

Obviously if you hurt others, you should right the wrongs as much as you can. You can’t take back what you did anymore than you can put toothpaste back in the tube,* but you can help set things right after the fact.

In the time of the Buddha, in the kingdom of Magadha, the prince Ajatasatru, then one of the Buddha’s lay disciples, overthrew his father and took the throne, then later waged war on the neighboring kingdom of Kosala. During this time, Ajatasatru supported the renegade Devadatta, who tried to pull monks away from the Buddha with his own teaching. Later in other Buddhist texts, Ajatasatru deeply regretted his actions and came before the Buddha to apologize. The Buddha was not angry, and said he was forgiven and welcomed him as a disciple again. Ajatasatru was present when the Buddha delivered sermons such as the Lotus Sutra and others, so it seems that he was a devout follower after that.

In Mahayana Buddhism (Northern Buddhism from Tibet to Japan), there is a sense of ritual to confessions, whereby one confesses them before the Buddha or Bodhisattva they devote themselves too. This seems to have begun in the last chapter of the Flower Garland Sutra, often treated as a separate text called the Gandavyuha Sutra, and has persisted more or less in the same format. One confesses something wrong that they did, and states that this action was entirely the result of their own ignorance, greed and/or hatred, and they vow not to commit that action again.

A really vivid example of a Buddhist confession is in the Golden Light Sutra. In this sutra the Bodhisattva Ruchiraketu in chapter 3 has had a dream about a great drum radiating a golden light (the Dharma). In chapter 4 he expresses his wish that all beings are awakened by the sound of this drum, and that he can become a refuge to such beings. Then the Bodhisattva confesses his misdeeds in the same chapter:

O buddhas possessed of the ten powers:
Those terrible wicked acts
I have committed in the past,
Before your eyes, I confess them all.

The Bodhisattva then lists the various categories of unwholesome deeds he may have committed before ending it with:

Through misdeeds of body, speech and mind,
I have amassed threefold wrong acts.
In these three ways, whatever I have done,
These deeds I confess in full.

And so on. The point here isn’t that one should follow this formula, or another, but rather that in all these acts of confession, from the simplest to the elaborate, the basic notion is the same. One should acknowledge what they’ve done wrong, and accept responsibility for it. We are all deluded beings, and we all do stupid things that we can’t take back. Too often though we blame others for things gone wrong, but regardless of what life throws at you, ultimately it’s through your own mind, body and speech that acts are committed, wholesome or unwholesome.

However, a wonderful act of humility is to admit when you’ve done wrong and apologize. It doesn’t have to be elaborate, but if it is sincere, and meant with wholesome intentions, it can be a wonderful gesture, and a way of setting the mind at ease. One cannot practice Buddhism well if one has such concerns eating away at them for a long time.

Namuamidabu

* – Where possible, it’s best to avoid the mistake if you can help it. That’s why Buddhists try to cultivate mindfulness, so they can become aware of what’s going on, not just blindly reacting people usually do.


Be the first to like this post.

3 Comments on “Confession in Buddhism”

  1. jayarava says:

    Hi Gerald,

    Haven’t looked in for a while but I’ve just spent an enjoyable half hour scanning through your recent posts. Many cross-overs with my own interests. Funnily enough I’ve spent many hours recently researching Ajatasattu’s confession to the Buddha in the Sāmaññaphala Sutta. Do you have a reference for Aj apologising for colluding with Devadatta? I’d be very interested to read that.

    In the SS he confesses to killing Bimbisara, despite having already inherited the Kingdom, a point you may have overlooked – Bimbisara abdicates in Aj’s favour and is still killed off! There are some tricky issues with what actually happens in the sutta and I am preparing an argument that the previous translators have misunderstood the scene – quite hubristic I suppose! But it has lead me to read all that I can on confession in early Buddhism. My impression is that Aj does not really experience remorse. I also argue that in the SS the Buddha can in no way be said to “forgive” Aj – the text does not say that, and it makes no sense in the context of early Buddhism. I hope to get this article published, but failing that I’ll put it on my own website.

    Keep up the good work!
    Best wishes
    Jayarava

  2. anon says:

    Confess your sins online, anonymously at http://iconfessmyself.blogspot.com

  3. Gerald Ford says:

    Hi Jayarava,

    The information I got about Ajatasatru and confession was found on Access to Insight, which is so large, I can’t find the source again. Try poking around there. To tell you the truth though, it’s quite likely I may have just misquoted.

    You may be right in that Ajatasatru wasn’t really sorry for what he did, he just wanted relief from the guilt, but I like to think that in a future rebirth there’s hope for him yet, and I think the Buddha saw that and forgave him nevertheless. If the Buddha can predict full Buddha-hood for Devadatta in the Lotus Sutra, just about anything is possible. :)


Leave a Reply

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

Please log in to WordPress.com to post a comment to your blog.

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. (Log Out)

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. (Log Out)

Connecting to %s